Why doesn't Shulchan Aruch include the laws of destroying fruit trees? The Next CEO of Stack OverflowAnonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy do we make a blessing on the blossoming of fruit trees (birkat hailanot)?Why is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Why is there such fervor to say the blessing on blossoming fruit trees?Who authored the topic - division headings in the Shulchan Aruch?Why isn't maakeh in the Tur?5th part of the shulchan aruchWhat is the Shulchan Aruch Ha'Arizal?Consistent philosophy in the Shulchan AruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch

Man transported from Alternate World into ours by a Neutrino Detector

Compilation of a 2d array and a 1d array

Can Sri Krishna be called 'a person'?

Can a PhD from a non-TU9 German university become a professor in a TU9 university?

How to implement Comparable so it is consistent with identity-equality

How to show a landlord what we have in savings?

How to find if SQL server backup is encrypted with TDE without restoring the backup

Is there a rule of thumb for determining the amount one should accept for of a settlement offer?

Why can't we say "I have been having a dog"?

Physiological effects of huge anime eyes

Ising model simulation

Is it reasonable to ask other researchers to send me their previous grant applications?

Simplify trigonometric expression using trigonometric identities

Incomplete cube

MT "will strike" & LXX "will watch carefully" (Gen 3:15)?

Horror film about a man brought out of cryogenic suspension without a soul, around 1990

What does this strange code stamp on my passport mean?

How to pronounce fünf in 45

What does it mean 'exit 1' for a job status after rclone sync

The sum of any ten consecutive numbers from a fibonacci sequence is divisible by 11

Early programmable calculators with RS-232

Free fall ellipse or parabola?

Masking layers by a vector polygon layer in QGIS

Traveling with my 5 year old daughter (as the father) without the mother from Germany to Mexico



Why doesn't Shulchan Aruch include the laws of destroying fruit trees?



The Next CEO of Stack OverflowAnonymous glosses in the Shulchan AruchWhy do we make a blessing on the blossoming of fruit trees (birkat hailanot)?Why is the Shulchan Aruch definitive?Why is there such fervor to say the blessing on blossoming fruit trees?Who authored the topic - division headings in the Shulchan Aruch?Why isn't maakeh in the Tur?5th part of the shulchan aruchWhat is the Shulchan Aruch Ha'Arizal?Consistent philosophy in the Shulchan AruchLearning to translate the Shulchan Aruch










3















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur







share|improve this question



















  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago















3















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur







share|improve this question



















  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago













3












3








3








Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur







share|improve this question
















Despite clear halachos that apply nowadays and codification in Rambam's Mishneh Torah, Rif, Rosh and Semag, and discussion by a host of other commentaries, as far as I (and the Taz, YD 116:6) can tell, the Tur and Shulchan Aruch do not discuss the laws of destroying trees/Bal Tashchis anywhere. Why is this? (Sources, please!)






halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur




halacha shulchan-aruch trees tur






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 3 hours ago







רבות מחשבות

















asked 3 hours ago









רבות מחשבותרבות מחשבות

14.6k129122




14.6k129122







  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago












  • 1





    It's not the only thing missing

    – Double AA♦
    3 hours ago






  • 2





    @DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

    – רבות מחשבות
    3 hours ago







1




1





It's not the only thing missing

– Double AA♦
3 hours ago





It's not the only thing missing

– Double AA♦
3 hours ago




2




2





@DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

– רבות מחשבות
3 hours ago





@DoubleAA certainly true, but I would ask questions on other cases that were discussed in earlier codes as well...

– רבות מחשבות
3 hours ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















2














R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







share|improve this answer






























    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes








    1 Answer
    1






    active

    oldest

    votes









    active

    oldest

    votes






    active

    oldest

    votes









    2














    R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



    Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




    גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



    There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







    share|improve this answer



























      2














      R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



      Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




      גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



      There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







      share|improve this answer

























        2












        2








        2







        R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



        Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




        גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



        There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.







        share|improve this answer













        R. Jacob Reischer addresses this in a responsum:



        Shu"t Shevut Yaakov 1:159




        גם על הטור אין תימא כל כך דאף דלאו בפירוש אתמר מכללא אתמר כיון דאיסור לקצוץ אילנות הוא לאו דוקא אלא ה"ה כל המאבד דרך השחתה עובר בלא תשחית כלשון הרמב"ם ואיסורא דבל תשחית מוזכר כמה פעמים בטור וכמבואר בי"ד הל' אבילות סי' שמ"ט וסי' ש"ן ע"ש והיתרא דמותר לקוץ במקום דמזיק לאחריני מבואר כמה פעמים בטור ח"מ סי' קנ"ה יע"ש כל זה נ"ל ברור



        There is also not such a question on the Tur, because even if it is not said explicitly it is said implicitly – since the prohibition of cutting trees is not specific, rather anyone who destroys in a destructive manner violates bal tashchit, as expressed by Rambam. And the prohibition of bal tashchit is mentioned many times in the Tur, as is clarified in Y.D. Hilchot Aveilut 349 and 350 see there. And the exemption that it is permissible to cut in a place where it harms others is clarified many times in the Tur, in C.M. 155 see there. All this seems clear to me.








        share|improve this answer












        share|improve this answer



        share|improve this answer










        answered 3 hours ago









        AlexAlex

        22.9k156130




        22.9k156130













            -

            Popular posts from this blog

            कुँवर स्रोत दिक्चालन सूची"कुँवर""राणा कुँवरके वंशावली"

            Image
            पुष्टि की ज़रूरत वाले "सम्बंधित जाति समूह" क्षत्रियक्षेत्रीकर्णालीक्षेत्रीनेपाली भाषामेंकाजीबिष्टपाण्डेबस्नेतथापावत्सपृथ्वीनारायण शाहकेबलभद्र कुंवरभीमसेन थापाकेजंगबहादुर राणाराणा कुँवर/कँवर (गोरखाली) उपर: रामकृष्ण कुँवर बीच:बलभद्र कुंवर  · बालनरसिंह कुँवर तल:जंगबहादुर कुँवर राणा  · बमबहादुर कुँवर राणा कुल जनसंख्या ८२,१४९ नेपालमे (राणा कुँवरको छोडके) [1] [2] ख़ास आवास क्षेत्र   नेपाल भाषाएँ नेपाली भाषा धर्म हिन्दु धर्म और मष्टो धर्म अन्य सम्बंधित समूह पाँडे, थापा, बस्नेत, बिष्ट कुँवर वा कँवर नेपाली क्षत्रिय वर्णके क्षेत्री जातिके पारिवारिक नाम है। इस परिवारकी उत्पत्ति नेपालके कर्णाली प्रदेशमे अन्य क्षेत्री जातिके साथ हुआ था। कुँवरका अर्थ नेपाली भाषामें कुमार है। यिनका भारतीय राजपुत और मराठा राजाओं से कुछ वैवाहिक सम्बन्ध है। भारतमे पाएजानेवाले कुँवर अलग वंशजके है। कुँवर पाँच पुस्त्यौनी काजी परिवार मध्ये एक है। अन्य चार परिवार बिष्ट, पाण्डे, बस्नेत और थापा है। [3] इनके गोत्र वत्स गोत्र है। [4] रामकृष्ण कुँवर पृथ्वीनारायण शाहके सेनामे सरदार थे। बलभद्र कुंवर भीमसेन थापाके
            Read more

            Why is a white electrical wire connected to 2 black wires?How to wire a light fixture with 3 white wires in box?How should I wire a ceiling fan when there's only three wires in the box?Two white, two black, two ground, and red wire in ceiling box connected to switchWhy is there a white wire connected to multiple black wires in my light box?How to wire a light with two white wires and one black wireReplace light switch connected to a power outlet with dimmer - two black wires to one black and redHow to wire a light with multiple black/white/green wires from the ceiling?Ceiling box has 2 black and white wires but fan/ light only has 1 of eachWhy neutral wire connected to load wire?Switch with 2 black, 2 white, 2 ground and 1 red wire connected to ceiling light and a receptacle?

            Image
            Why one should not leave fingerprints on bulbs and plugs? New passport but visa is in old (lost) passport How to pronounce "I ♥ Huckabees"? Fastest way to pop N items from a large dict Why does energy conservation give me the wrong answer in this inelastic collision problem? Is there a place to find the pricing for things not mentioned in the PHB? (non-magical) Why did it take so long to abandon sail after steamships were demonstrated? Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D minor breaks the "no parallel octaves" rule? Problem with FindRoot Why do passenger jet manufacturers design their planes with stall prevention systems? Print a physical multiplication table "of which" is correct here? Why is the President allowed to veto a cancellation of emergency powers? Can I use USB data pins as power source How difficult is it to simply disable/disengage the MCAS on Boeing 737 Max 8 & 9 Aircraft? As a new Ubuntu desktop 18.04 LTS user,
            Read more

            चैत्य भूमि चित्र दीर्घा सन्दर्भ बाहरी कडियाँ दिक्चालन सूची"Chaitya Bhoomi""Chaitya Bhoomi: Statue of Equality in India""Dadar Chaitya Bhoomi: Statue of Equality in India""Ambedkar memorial: Centre okays transfer of Indu Mill land"चैत्यभमि

            Image
            मुम्बईबौद्ध तीर्थ स्थलभीमराव आंबेडकर को समर्पित स्मारक मुंबईदादरभारतीय संविधानडॉ भीमराव आंबेडकरबौद्ध धर्मदिल्लीमहापरिनिर्वाणमुंबईभदन्त आनन्द कौशल्यायनअरबी समुद्र चैत्यभूमि चैत्यभूमि मुंबई के दादर स्थित भारतीय संविधान के निर्माता भारतरत्न डॉ भीमराव आंबेडकर जी की समाधि स्थली और बौद्ध धर्म के लोगो का आस्था का केंद्र हैं। दादर के समुद्र तट पर चैत्य भूमि स्थित है। [1] [2] [3] [4] दिल्ली में अपने निवास में ६ दिसंबर १९५६ को आंबेडकर का महापरिनिर्वाण हुआ और उनका पार्थिव मुंबई में लाया गया, चैत्यभूमि में ७ दिसंबर १९५६ को भदन्त आनन्द कौशल्यायन ने आंबेडकर का बौद्ध परम्परा के अनुसार दाह संस्कार किया था। आंबेडकर का दाह संस्कार के पहले उन्हें साक्षी रख उनके १०,००,००० अनुयायिओं ने बौद्ध धम्म की दीक्षा ली और यह दीक्षा उन्हें भदन्त आनन्द कौशल्यायन ने दी थी। चित्र दीर्घा चैत्यभूमि स्तूप अशोकस्तंभ अशोकस्तंभ व प्रवेशद्वार (अंदर से) प्रवेशद्वार (अंदर से) चैत्यभूमि परिसर, आगे अशोकस्तंभ और अरबी समुद्र चैत्यभूम
            Read more